In the first paragraph, while you identify the semantic field of nature, the analysis lacks depth. Instead of just listing words, explain how they contribute to the overall meaning and tone of each poem. For example, discuss how the words in 'Today' create a sense of joy and liberation, while in 'Autumn' they evoke a sense of loss and disruption.
The second paragraph mentions enjambment but does not clearly explain its effect in both poems. Instead of stating that it mirrors pauses in thought, elaborate on how enjambment affects the flow and emotional impact of the poems. Provide specific examples from the texts to support your points.
In the third paragraph, you discuss free verse but could enhance your analysis by explaining how the lack of a fixed structure in both poems reflects the themes of freedom and chaos. Consider providing examples of how the form contributes to the reader's understanding of the poets' attitudes towards the seasons.
The essay demonstrates a clear understanding of the poems and attempts to compare the poets' attitudes towards the seasons. The identification of literary devices such as semantic fields, enjambment, and free verse shows an awareness of the methods used by the poets.
To achieve a higher mark, focus on providing more detailed analysis of the methods used in both poems. Instead of just identifying techniques, explain their effects and how they contribute to the overall themes and attitudes presented. Use specific quotes and examples to strengthen your arguments.
The essay presents a basic comparison of the two poems, identifying some key methods used by the poets. However, the analysis lacks depth and clarity in explaining how these methods create meaning and effect. To improve, focus on providing more detailed and insightful comparisons, using specific examples from the texts to support your points.