In the first paragraph, while you effectively discuss the contrast between black and white, you could enhance your analysis by providing more specific textual references to support your claims. For example, instead of just stating 'black shadow' and 'white snow', you could explain how these images interact within the context of the narrative. Additionally, consider elaborating on how this contrast specifically impacts the reader's emotional response, perhaps by discussing the implications of fear and uncertainty in more detail.
In the second paragraph, you introduce the idea of Rosamond's vulnerability well, but the analysis could be more cohesive. The transition between discussing the weather and Rosamond's condition feels a bit abrupt. Try to create a clearer connection between the harshness of the environment and its emotional impact on Rosamond. Also, when discussing the phrase 'and at last, oh!', it would be beneficial to clarify what this moment signifies for both Rosamond and the reader, as this will strengthen your argument about the emotional release.
The essay demonstrates a clear understanding of Gaskell's techniques in evoking strong emotions through contrast and vivid imagery. The analysis of the black and white imagery, as well as the description of the harsh weather, effectively illustrates how these elements contribute to the reader's emotional experience.
To achieve a higher mark, focus on providing more detailed textual references and clearer connections between your points. Ensure that each paragraph flows logically into the next, and consider deepening your analysis of how specific phrases and images affect the reader's emotions.
Overall, the essay presents a thoughtful evaluation of how Gaskell creates strong emotions in the text. The use of contrast and vivid descriptions is well identified, but the analysis would benefit from more detailed textual evidence and clearer connections between ideas. Strengthening these areas will enhance the overall coherence and depth of your response.